I think this is the point we're both trying to make, and it's pretty well illustrated in both of our posts. You think they feel very different, and I think they feel very similar (these two specific gloves). Saying to someone "get this glove Y because it feels like your current glove X" will be very subjective, and so I don't think it's very helpful.
Instead of comparing generic break angles, etc. I think it may be more useful to talk specifically about what people like in their gloves internally: do your fingers spread out inside the palm, how much wiggle room is there in the finger stalls (and do you like that), what angle you hold your wrist at, what angle the glove tries to put your wrist at, do you wear the back hand loose or crank it down tight (and where those straps are on your hand can play a huge role in comfort), and a myriad of other little details that all combine to make up a glove that we enjoy using.