Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Abraham Simpson

Bauer S190 vs 1S blocker & glove: One-year durability review

Recommended Posts

Here's Part 2 of the S190 vs 1S durability comparison, which covers the blockers and gloves. 

As before, many of the variables were similar in terms of usage of the gear:

-- S190 glove and blocker were used for about 250 ice sessions from July 2017 to July 2018

-- 1S glove and blocker were used for about 250 ice sessions from July 2018 to July 2019 (gear purchased at 40% discount from list price in summer of 2018)

-- Shooters were mostly 14 to 17-year-olds

Some key differences:

-- S190 glove and blocker are INT, while 1S glove and blocker are SR

-- 1S glove and blocker were made in Canada by JRZ. Production of the 1S line was eventually moved overseas, so this suggests we may have early production units of the 1S gear.

1s_jrz.thumb.jpg.cbd2cdc484a16f50fa42ce96e9a2b65e.jpg

As with the pads, the 1S blocker outperforms the S190 blocker (it's lighter, has better padding and protection, and sends the puck far from the net with little effort), but it also suffers from lower durability (the stitching is a problem, and the palm has more wear). Meanwhile, the gloves are wearing-out at roughly the same rate, although the 1S binding is wearing-out faster. However, the performance gain of the 1S glove just isn't there: Although it has a thicker padding to reduce stingers, it's been impossible to break-in, even after 250 ice sessions.

1. Blockers

Here's a view of both blockers. The additional finger protection and inner padding of the 1S are key benefits over the 190. The 1S is also light, and sends pucks far into the corners with little effort, so in terms or performance and protection, the 1S is the clear winner. 

I circled the palms to show some of the wear (hard to see in black), and both palms are wearing-out at roughly the same rate.

blockers.thumb.jpg.27a30f9ceffc51cfd2d4dabf555c7e99.jpg

However, some problems are found with the durability of the 1S fingers: Small holes are beginning to appear, while the thumb is completely worn-out. It's starting to look like a hobo glove:

1s_blocker_thumb2.thumb.jpg.91c212166edd6f59af69c4541baf48a7.jpg

Another area where the 1S has problems is the stitching, which we also found faulty on the 1S pads. My wife had to break-out her needle and thread mid-season to fix the top of the blocker, and was at it again to fix a larger tear in the same area two weeks ago (her blue thread is circled in this picture). This part of the blocker is hard to fix when the stitching comes apart, since there's not much surplus material to stitch back together.

1s_blocker_stitches.thumb.jpg.c20ceaf379e5ad82c7ff20e2bfd4cbd0.jpg

An area where both blockers suffer is the side wall near the thumb, which rubs against the shaft of the stick. Visible, and nearly identical, holes (that can't be fixed with needle and thread), exist for both blockers:

1S:

 1s_blocker_thumb.thumb.jpg.66a0db14768399951dec2a83fbf2d85f.jpg

S190:

190_blocker_thumb.thumb.jpg.2b60dee27316f78e9fb5004e717f9cdc.jpg

2. Gloves

Here are side-by-side pictures of both gloves. Based on puck marks, it looks like they've seen a similar amount of action. However, an obvious difference between the two is the inability of the 1S to fully open. We've had a lot of success in getting gloves game-ready by baking them, but the 1S would never cooperate: We've baked it twice, but it was still impossible to fully close. Then we resorted to soaking it in hot water, which has helped to close it, but it never opens as wide as it should. Even today, if the glove dries-out, it needs to be moistened before hitting the ice.

The main reason the 1S glove is being used instead of the 190 is the extra padding in its palm -- the 190 is just too thin for the type of shots that my kid faces, and the stingers are very real. So performance-wise, the glove has been the only disappointment in the 1S line.

In terms of durability, both gloves have minor issues: The lacing on the 190 is thinning (although it hasn't yet ripped), while the black binding on the 1S is wearing-out, much like it is on the 1S pads. This is surprising, considering the binding only comes into contact with the ice when covering the puck. Makes me wonder whether Bauer is using a thinner and lighter binding on the 1S in order to shave a few grams off the total weight of the gear -- but does so at the cost of lower durability.

gloves.thumb.jpg.7e06b6c45794649b6a7b17ce11b69757.jpg

Conclusion:

In terms of performance and protection, the 1S pads and blocker are fantastic. The 1S glove is good for protection, but performance has been terrible: Pucks initially were bouncing out when the glove wouldn't fully close, and now that it doesn't fully open, it leaves more of the net exposed.

In terms of overall durability, the 1S gear is worse, or at best no better than, the 190. This raises a question about the old rule of thumb: Use cheaper gear if you're on the ice 2-3 times per week, and higher-end gear if you're on the ice 5-6 times per week. Clearly, if you're on the ice 5-6 times per week, don't expect to get more than one season out of your 1S gear. 

Some of the durability issues of the 1S have undoubtedly been addressed with the 2S and 2X lines, thanks to a stronger version of Coretech and less exposed binding, which are two problem areas in our experience. Unless Bauer is also now using a stronger thread, I still expect the stitching will still be an area of concern due to similarities in the design of Bauer lines. We'll monitor the stitching closely on any new Bauer gear that we get.

On that topic: The kid recently demoed the 2X gear at the Bauer store in Burlington, MA -- expect our one-year 2X durability review next summer ...

2x.jpg.5db84fde082832bf7692ce755fa38d47.jpg

  • Like 2
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It almost seems that the 1S material is difficult to get a good bite with the thread when sewn. That is bizarre stuff.

Again- thanks for the review.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 7/30/2019 at 3:35 PM, Abraham Simpson said:

1s_blocker_stitches.thumb.jpg.c20ceaf379e5ad82c7ff20e2bfd4cbd0.jpg

I red also the pad review. Those gear saw pretty much action, some regular beer leaguer see as much pucks in 10 years. I guess user and co players were younger when using S190 than 1S. 

Is stitching failed originally because of a skate cut?

I haven´t heard too much problems with 1S gloves but durability of pads were terrible. It was so bad design that Bauer (and maybe some other manufacturers) started to speak about performance, not durabality when they talked about pro pads, it was 10 years ago when pro pads lasted twice what SR pads. Pro models are now so light that SR models are often more or even durable. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Who's Online   14 Members, 0 Anonymous, 53 Guests (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    1,231
    Total Members
    2,646
    Most Online
    Derek
    Newest Member
    Derek
    Joined
  • Similar Content

    • By BCZ
      I'm looking to make the leap into custom gear. I'm currently in SLR 1s (32+2) with VE8 mitts (used to have VE8 pads as well, but really disliked them). Looking for input on moving into a new company; I've been looking at Bauer or Brians - particularly because custom options allow for a smaller palm on the mitts. I've read that while Vapor is more of a hybrid pad - it still kicks out some big rebounds (also - I wear a 2x pro c/a, and figure the same ecosystem ensures a better fit). I've tried the strapping on the Vapors and find it very comfortable. I've also heard a lot of good things about the O2 mitts and the max core. Seeking additional input before I throw down $3k on pads. Thanks in advance for all your help. 
    • By Abraham Simpson
      Does anyone know if Bauer is planning on updating/tweaking its 960xpm mask in the next 12 months? I need to invest in a new bucket before next season, and was wondering whether a new model might be in the offering (in which case I could get the 960xpm at a discount).
    • By BadAngle41
      Qty (2) Bauer NME Certified Straight Bar Senior Replacement Cages
      Received them with my new NME VTX but immediately swapped out for a Cateye... so these are unused and brand new. I posted them on SidelineSwap... but I'm really just wanting to see them go to someone who will use them... so I'm asking the buyer to cover the shipping cost only. 
      Please only respond if you have a true need for them and you're not just going to turn around and try to sell them. Happy to break them up if you're only looking for (1)... just let me know.
      Shipping from USA Zip Code 46202 via USPS if you'd like to check on shipping cost.


×
×
  • Create New...